Cheap Flights from New York to Indianapolis
Looking for cheap flights from New York to Indianapolis? PointsYeah scans award availability across major airline and bank transfer programs in one place, so travelers can compare the lowest points and cash routes faster. Instead of searching each airline separately, users can see pricing from programs like Chase, Amex, Capital One, Citi, and Bilt side by side.
Award prices from New York to Indianapolis vary by season and date, but economy flights can start around 13,000 points one way, with premium cabins available at higher mileage levels. The live search above allows filtering by cabin, airline, stops, or maximum points to find the best award flights from New York to Indianapolis for specific travel dates.
2026-05-02
JFK - IND
Economy | Non stop
From 13,000 Pts + $5.6
2026-05-02
LGA - IND
Economy | Non stop
From 13,000 Pts + $5.6
2026-05-03
LGA - IND
Economy | 1 Stop
From 13,000 Pts + $5.6
2026-05-03
JFK - IND
Economy | 1 Stop
From 13,000 Pts + $5.6
2026-05-04
JFK - IND
Economy | Non stop
From 13,000 Pts + $5.6
2026-05-04
LGA - IND
Economy | 1 Stop
From 13,000 Pts + $5.6
Premium cabin flights from New York to Indianapolis
Premium cabin
2026-05-02
JFK - IND
First | 1 Stop | 4 left
From 39,300 Pts + $5.6
Premium cabin
2026-05-02
JFK - IND
First | 1 Stop
From 24,000 Pts + $5.6
Premium cabin
2026-05-02
LGA - IND
First | Non stop
From 24,000 Pts + $5.6
Premium cabin
2026-05-02
LGA - IND
First | Non stop | 4 left
From 43,600 Pts + $5.6
Premium cabin
2026-05-03
JFK - IND
First | 1 Stop
From 24,000 Pts + $5.6
Premium cabin
2026-05-03
LGA - IND
First | Non stop
From 24,000 Pts + $5.6
Selected hotels for your next stay
Columbus (United States)
Hotel Indigo Columbus Architectural Center
From 22,100 Pts or $173
Indianapolis (United States)
InterContinental Hotels Indianapolis
From 34,000 Pts or $239
Indianapolis, IN (USA)
Conrad Indianapolis
From 75,000 Pts or $220
Frequently Asked Questions
The cheapest route from New York to Indianapolis depends on award space, transfer bonuses, and travel dates. PointsYeah compares bank and airline programs in one place so you can find the best points and cash combinations faster.
Yes. Transferable points from Chase, Amex, Capital One, Citi, and Bilt can often be moved to airline partners for flights from New York to Indianapolis.
Yes. Searching metro codes when available helps compare nearby airport combinations for flights from New York to Indianapolis.
Our mission is to provide
the simplest and best
points travel planning
experience. Yeah!
Our mission is to provide the simplest and best
points travel planning experience. Yeah!
